Threads Logo Threads Logo Facebook Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram Favorite Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Close Icon Video Play Icon Indicator Arrow Icon Close Icon Hamburger/Search Icon Plus Icon

Project Runway All Stars, Episode 1: “You Got Punked”

Oct 25, 2013
Article Image

Elena Slivnyak's winning design (and first ever challenge win)

Last night marked the beginning of Project Runway All Stars Season 3. With eleven returning designers (three of which were previous winners), a new host, and a prize package worth over $750,000, this is definitely a season you won’t want to miss!

The episode began with a rundown of the show’s new additions including Alyssa Milano as the host, and Marie Claire senior fashion editor, Zanna Roberts Rassi, as the new mentor. Isaac Mizrahi and Georgina Chapman also returned as judges. As the designers gathered to hear their challenge, three previous winners were unexpectedly introduced to the mix: Jeffery Sebelia (season 3), Irina Shabeyeva (season 6), and Seth Aaron Henderson (season 7). I’m sure you can imagine how this went over with the rest of the group.

This week’s challenge was to create your own version of a punk rock look for the runway, inspired by Debbie Harry’s exclusive new music. (It was later revealed that the winning design would be worn by Debbie, herself.) Designers were given thirty minutes to sketch before being sent to Mood. The twist was that no one was allowed to come back until their garments were complete. Luckily, a makeshift workroom was set up in the store for designers to sew their garments on-site. Why do you think they did this?

While some designers were more confident than others in their ability to create a punk rock look, the judges were quite impressed with the end results. Elena Slivnyak secured her first win ever on Project Runway, while Ari South was sent home.

On to the designs…

The top three:

Season 10 designer, Elena Slivnyak’s WINNING design:

Elena's winning design

Season 3 winner, Jeffrey Sebelia’s design:

Jeffrey's design

Season 7 winner, Seth Aaron Henderson’s design:

Seth Aaron's design

The bottom three:

Season 8 designer, Ari (formerly Andy) South’s losing design:

Ari's design

Season 9 designer, Viktor Luna’s design:

Viktor's design

Season 10 designer, Melissa Fleis’ design:

Melissa's design 

The rest of the looks:

Season 10 designer, Christopher Palu’s design:

 Christopher's design

Season 11 designer, Daniel Esquivel’s design:

Daniel's design

Season 6 winner, Irina Shabayeva’s design:

Irina's design

Season 5 designer, Korto Momolu’s design:

Korto's design

Season 3 designer, Mychael Knight’s design:

Mychael's design

While I was pleasantly surprised by Elena’s win, I had no idea she would even make it into the top three. This season is definitely going to be intense with just ten talented designers remaining, and nine more weeks to go.

Who are you most excited to see back on the runway, and what was your favorite punk look this week? Did you think Zanna Roberts Rassi was too harsh on the designers during their workroom critique? She specifically was not impressed with Elena’s jacket, which ended up winning. Share your thoughts below!

Sign up for the Threads Eletter

Get the latest from Threads delivered straight to your inbox.


Threads Insider

Get instant access to hundreds of videos, tutorials, patterns and more.

Start Your Free Trial

Already an Insider? Log in

Subscribe to Threads today

Save up to 37% and get a free gift



  1. user-574200 November 6th

    I agree with MissPat.

    "Winning"? "Designers"? and posted in Threads magazine?

  2. User avater krawz November 4th

    Really was surprised that Debbie Harry thought Elena's design was "punk" - it was an 80's look to me. And also that this beat out Seth Aaron's look?! Not a good start...

  3. User avater MissPat October 31st

    Sorry, they all look like so much trash to me. Not really interested in this season of "winning designers?".

  4. User avater jroach October 30th

    I agree with you, "kpmarcks". :)

  5. kpmarcks October 29th

    It was the model who suggested turning the jacket backwards. I thought it was poor behavior on Elena's part to not mention that.

Log in or create an account to post a comment.

More From Threads

Threads Insider Exclusives

View All
View All


  • Sign up for the Threads Eletter

    Get the latest from Threads delivered straight to your inbox.

  • SewStylish


    Take a look inside the pages of SewStylish Spring 2017.

  • CraftStylish


    Expert craft tutorials, news, and tips for sewing, knitting, crochet, quilting, paper crafts, embroidery, jewelry making, and more!